Alan Irvine...let's look on the bright side!

New Albion boss, Alan Irvine

I have been trying hard to find it in my heart to accept Alan Irvine, who has done nothing wrong in taking the Albion job - though he must surely have expected some disappointment from fans.  So, in the spirit of peace (not Peace)  and harmony  I have outlined below the reasons why his appointment may not be all that bad after all.  So, [deep breath] here goes:

• from all reports he is a good man on the training ground
• he will bring on our young academy players in the same way he helped bring through Everton's young talent
• talented fringe players like George Thorne may get more of a chance under Irvine and be more content at the club
• he is a British manager - a rare species in the PL these days
• it is clear that Albion is not a stepping stone to bigger and better things for Irvine, whereas if we had employed Sherwood and he had proved successful he would have upsticks and moved on taking our best players with him (remember what Big Ron did when he left for Utd)
• He is cheap...well relatively and on a 12 month rolling contract so if things go bad the club can change course fairly easily
• he seems like a fairly decent guy with a good attitude and someone who fits the club well
• he has already helped to attract the potential signature of Joleon Lescott, a quality centre back             

So there we go.  Seven great reasons to help us accept Alan Irvine to our club and help us get over our disappointment at the club's apparent lack of real ambition. Let's hope the new season starts well.

Jeremy Peace's biggest gamble yet!

Is Jeremy Peace taking a risky gamble on Alan Irvine?

Albion's communication officers have been working hard to sound upbeat about the arrival of Alan Irvine, as they must.  From the comments I have read they have been stressing his coaching ability and making it clear that the criteria for appointing Mr Irvine are the same principles behind the hiring of Misters Di Matteo, Clark and Hodgson.  In other words, the club is hiring a Head Coach and NOT a manager.  In this respect Irvine's appointment is similar to that of Clarke - both number twos to successful PL managers in Moyes (Everton) and Mourinho (Chelsea) respectively.  A convenient line has been drawn under Irvine's own forays into management - with his roles at Preston NE and Sheffield Wednesday apparently unmentioned and seemingly irrelevant.

Of course, it is the fans who have less selective ways of assessing their new manager.  They look at the full CV and not those highlights that are being used to justify his selection.  And it is this very reason that makes Jeremy Peace's decision to hire Alan Irvine one that may come back to bite - and bite hard!  In the past  fans have gone along with Peace's decisions because they believed they were being made in the interests of the club and based on sound principles.  This time that is not the case.  If Irvine fails, then Peace's chairmanship will also be seen to have failed in providing responsible and rational stewardship. It could mean that come Xmas Albion will be seeking both a new coach/manager and a new boardroom chief.

Fans really want to know why Jeremy Peace has made this decision.  It is truly confusing.  He knew Albion had to get back on track after a terrible season and he promised lessons had been learned.  Fans accepted that this was true.  But now many of us are scratching our heads wondering whether he has suffered recent amnesia or is in denial about the weaknesses behind the 2013-4 season.  Most fans feel Peace is trying to run the club too cheaply.   But again, why would he risk PL status just to save on hiring extra backroom staff or a manager with a proven record?

What is truly perplexing is that the fans have not been properly respected and the decision making progress not one that makes them feel their club is being treated the way it should be.  Time will tell if Peace is right or wrong in choosing Alan Irvine but he stands to lose heavily if Albion suffer an early run of defeats next season or demonstrate poor organisation on the pitch - expect major fan unrest.

So spin that wheel Mr Peace!

  

Alan Irvine - shock appointment!!

New WBA manager, Alan Irvine

So Albion have plumped for a young up and coming British manager, have they?  Er, not!  With Tim Sherwood seemingly wanting a larger slice of cake than the Albion board wanted to dish out, they have lurched for Alan Irvine.  It is a decision that leaves fans wondering whether Mr Peace and co. really have lost touch.  We know why they have opted for Mr Irvine, don't we?  He has been placed on a 12 month rolling contract and will not upset the existing structure that keeps Keith Downing and Dean Kiely securely in their places.  In other words, Irvine is cheap and can be got rid off without fuss if results do not go to play in 2014-15.

In fact, it is very possible that Mr Irvine will serve as a provisional choice.  I would be very surprised if Albion didn't continue their manager hunt behind the scenes just in case things don't go well next season. But it also begs the question, why get rid of Pepe Mel only to replace him with a manager whose credentials are inferior? (At least Pepe had led a side into the Europa league, was well respected in Spain and could have attracted decent Spanish talent to The Hawthorns!)

Another question: where does all this leave us?  With little ambition clearly.  So Alan Irvine is going to help WBA attract the names and the talent we need to compete in the PL?  Somehow I doubt it.  He doesn't even have direct PL experience as a manager as far as I know, but is a Championship man who has enjoyed only mixed success with Preston NE and Sheffield Wednesday. To say I was shocked at his appointment is not to overstate it.

I think Jeremy Peace is walking a rather thin line with fans now.  He cannot argue that he wants the best for the club with this appointment.  Nor can he tell us he is backing a man, as with Mowbray and Di Matteo, who deserves a chance to shine.  Irvine offers us no surprises outside of his actual appointment to the Head Coach job.

So sorry, but I am one Albion fan who is already preparing himself to write off the coming season.

Why are we waiting?

Pre-season countdown is on!

Once again we Albion fans find ourselves waiting around for news and updates on new personnel.  It was difficult enough last season with even Steve Clarke complaining at the lack of transfer activity.  But this year makes last year seem like a positively hectic period.  Not only do we have no manager appointed well into June, but we have 11 players out and only one in.  Meanwhile the clock is ticking and pre-season planning is on hold as we wait to find out who the Albion board will select to lead us into the 2014-5 season.

So far a whole host of names have been put forward, only for the bookies odds to lengthen and finally for the front runners to drop out completely.  We've had Laudrup, Moyes, Lennon, Hughton, Jones and Round to name just a few - not to mention Hoddle and Jol!  Are we really so bereft of direction as a club that we have no clear strong favourite in mind?  What's for sure is without a sense of leadership the quality of our signings will not be strong.  Clarke stuck his head above the parapit last year and having publically stated his dissatisfaction with the club's transfer ambition got Anichebe (unfortunately, in my view) and Sessignon (a bit better) signed up but for heavily inflated fees.  However, who is going to join us until they know a bit about where the club is coming from and where it is heading?

So, the clock keeps ticking and no doubt a new manager will be announced soon.  But I have a strong suspicion that whoever is named will not satisfy the fans.  And that means that our future signings may also be expedient ones too - players on free transfers, the odd loan here and there and former big names but now looking to earn a few final paycheques before retiring...sound familiar? 

So here's to the summer and all that it holds for WBA...I really hope I am wrong and that the board comes up with the goods this year.  After the season gone, the fans really deserve more!

And the new manager of WBA is...(drum roll, please)

Could Michael Laudrup be the new head coach for WBA?

So we continue to wait the outcome of Mr Peace's negotiations and interviews.  But one name bandied about this week has been that of Michael Laudrup.  Certainly, a figure like that could be one that fits the bill for Albion.  Firstly, he is currently out of contract after being sacked by Swansea, so there would be no costly compensation issues.  Second, he is a name that senior and younger players would look up to and respect - which was not the case with Pepe Mel from all reports.  Next up, he did well at Swansea and kept them playing attractive and attacking football.  In fact, a bit like with Steve Clark, his sacking was something of a surprise and slightly premature given that Swansea still had a lot to play for.  For my money, I think Laudrup would be a good fit - a foreign coach who will bring a bit of panache to The Hawthorns, but one who speaks great English and has Premier League experience!

If Laudrup's strengths are compared with British managers currently available he stands up well.  How many have Europa league experience, for example?  How many play genuinely attacking football?  None, I can think of.  But would Laudrup be interested in Albion? Let's face it, he is probably aiming for a bigger club than ours.  The lure of the PL is a strong one though.  Maybe he will feel there is unfinished business between him and the English game too. His personality might well fit with Jeremy Peace too - a mild mannered guy who is unlikely to court controversy.  So the final question is whether Laudrup could remain within the current club structure - particularly when it comes to transfer budgets.  Well, why not?

If not Laudrup, then I would like to see Keith Downing get a second try.  Maybe his appointment would be less good when it comes to attracting new players to the club but he was a hit with the squad last year.  

Anyway, this week we should find out who the new man will be.